Which Martial Art is the Better One, Karate or Aikido?

I know, the question is a bit bogus, as one should bebring the arms up to catch the elbow, shove your
comparing arts such as Karate and Aikido merely soshoulder in and go with the flow. Go ahead, try this
as to make them compliment each other. Thus, withtechnical adaptation, even gaze at a little youtube to
that statement made, let us discuss how the fistget the idea of the geometries involved, and you are
should wiggle into the glove. No pow and bam, justgoing to find an instant blend of karate, even the
an honest, up front viewpoint for your edification andhardest of karate, like Kyukoshinkai, with even the
enlightenment. Karate is supposed to be straight line,purest forms of Aikido, even the soft form
and Aikido is supposed to be the circle. Yet, if onespoused by Morihei Uyeshiba. Now, the above
looks at Karate, let alone the martial arts, one will seetechnique being examined, the glaring weakness of
that perfection of geometric figure is loose, at best.Karate is that it is limited, in most modern classes, to
If Karate could actually adhere to the perfect line, ifthe fact of destruction. It has been altered to win
one examines how the bones, joints, muscles and sothe tournament, beat the other guy for a trophy,
on function, the body would probably explode, or, atand gloves are used for more violence, and fighting is
least collapse upon itself. On the other hand, if Aikidodone for fighting sake. But, I have been guilty of
tried to adhere to the perfect circle and only theshouting this from the mountain tops, while there is
perfect circle, except in the most theoretical ofan art to destruction, the true art is in control. Thus,
philosophies, the art would not work. And, to bea study of the pure art of Aikido, with the things I
honest, Aikido is not the usual choice for down andhave told you here, will enable you to confront the
dirty combat. While Aikido is pure and wonderful, andfiercest violence, and alter that violence into the
can evolve the practitioner in very spiritual senses,most magical and simplest of workable techniques.
one should use a martial art like Karate to enter theYou kick, you punch, then you simply embrace the
fight, then look to aikido to control the fight. Thinkarms and learn how to go with the flow. A last word
about it this way, a fight is the collapse of distance.about all this, don't mistake the throws of judo or
The length of the arm, and the circle being made, thejujitsu for Aikido techniques. While techniques of the
lever of the extend arm is too long. However, if youju variety are wonderful, we want to move from
want magic, use karate to kick, punch, find yourselfhard to soft complete, and a certain amount of hard
on the inside as the distance collapses, and then useis still involved in ju techniques. That all said, I wish
a shorter lever. Instead of stepping in and trying toyou the best with your new art, and a new art it
make a three foot arm circle into a wrist lock, try ais...karido...aikate...your choice.
middle block, slide in and begin turning. As you turn,